You Can See Everything is a careful, multi-sided examination of a new species of lying just recently evolved out of the digital age and immune, so far, to all of our attempts to neutralize it. At its center is Elizabeth Holmes, the notorious scam artist who convinced the world that a drop of blood could yield a treasure trove of medical information. Orbiting around her as she departs for prison are three bystanders, each persuaded, even if they won’t all admit it, that she isn’t as bad as people think.
This supporting cast isn’t highly interesting, except for how they all excuse Elizabeth for unrelated, contradictory reasons. There’s Billy, her controlling, narcissistic boyfriend, who believes that her only flaw, essentially, is purity of heart—that she’s so femininely virtuous that exposing her again to the aggressive, cutthroat world of corporate tech investment (without his guiding, masculine hand) would be tantamount to cruelty. There’s Amanda Seyfried, who played Elizabeth in a Hulu series and claims a sisterly bond with her, who recoils hurt when Elizabeth rails against her performance and fantasizes about freeing Elizabeth of the odious, supposedly abusive Billy. (By implication, she was a victim, too, of Sunny Balwani, her Theranos co-chief and then-partner; indeed, snippets of Amanda’s portrayal of Elizabeth show her facing office sexism.) Finally, there’s Nathan Fielder, the socially challenged documentarist who can’t shake the idea that his interviews with Elizabeth at a rented beach house meant something more: that, somehow, they represented an interpersonal breakthrough for him, if only temporary. And if he could only recapture it…
That all of these people are wrong about Elizabeth is obvious, but the evidence for their wrongness is difficult to find because she herself is so passive, even vacant, when pressed on any meaningful point about her actions. This is exactly the source of her influence. She’s not a scammer, exactly, but an enabler and magnifier of others’ scams: the scams they perpetrate against their own selves. For example, that they’re bringing manly firmness back to a pussified world (Billy, who spends much time looking at himself in the mirror), that they’re a feminist champion of abused women (Amanda, who torched Elizabeth’s reputation and lives on a beautiful horse ranch), that they’re the epitome of a trustworthy friend (Nathan, who’s made a career of tricking regular people into making fools of themselves).
Of course, we’ve been deceiving ourselves at least since Don Quixote took arms against a windmill, but this, maybe, is something more extreme. And the culprit isn’t hard to identify. Confrontations in this movie, like when an industry veteran factually summarizes Elizabeth’s Theranos crimes in front of Billy only for him to erupt and demand a halt to the conversation, are so explosive because it seems that nothing like them has ever occurred before: if not for Nathan, none of these people would have to confront that they aren’t remotely who they say they are, that their realities are inaccessible to other people. Their lives instead occur online, as when Amanda polarizes users on X by criticizing Charlie Kirk—staking an identity, not earning one—rather than in the actual world, as when she has to watch Elizabeth cry through her Hulu performance.
In an ecosystem like that, there’s no longer power in assertiveness, in imposing one’s will, since that’s simply not possible when the entire population has digitally validated themselves beyond questioning. Even sycophancy is iffy, since it risks mis-repeating a fantasy or bringing attention to its dubiousness. The power, now, is all in acquiescence, in not doubting, in staring into a person’s eyes and letting them repeat whatever story they want. And Elizabeth Holmes could be our foremost practitioner in the art.
Is she a liar? I would say yes, by commission. If not, then she’s worse: a kind of zookeeper of others’ lies—sheltering them, feeding them, helping them grow until they’re dangerous enough to wreak havoc out in the world, at which time she can reap the benefits, monetary or social. During the closing minutes of You Can See Everything, three highly successful adults vie for Elizabeth’s attention while she’s in prison for fraud, and we see her in the yard, separated from us by bars. But as Nathan, fresh off a romantic breakup, wistfully remembers an exhilarating ocean swim with Elizabeth, it’s worth asking: who’s on the outside of the prison, and who’s on the inside?
–Jim Andersen